Ok Folks, Show’s Over. Please Return Your hats.
I feel I have spent a lifetime studying dictators. It’s an unusual hobby, and sometimes when I feel compelled to talk about them, I am moved to the other end of the table at dinner parties.
I never liked them, not the dinner party hosts, the dictators.
What I always wanted to know was why so many perfectly sensible people followed them, slavishly, off a cliff. Charisma? Charm? An air of authority? Maybe. But one thread runs through them all: dishonesty. Mussolini on his balcony, Hitler in the stadium: each betrayed the very people who worshipped at his feet, yet the worshippers kept cheering anyway.
An honest speaker can move a crowd too. Think of Obama. The difference is in what’s being fed. An honest man lifts people towards something. A dishonest one targets the weakest, angriest part of each person and hand-feeds them the poison.
Which brings us to the endless rallies we have endured over the past two years. It’s the longest-running touring show of the last decade. It was so repetitive that attendees didn’t need to be told the setlist, as the old hits arrived in the same order every night; the lies grew slightly taller with each tour, and the crowd was always, miraculously, the biggest anyone had ever seen.
Break it all down, and it was just a tribute act, except that in this case the tribute band was also the original.
Like any tired touring show, there was merchandise, naturally. Caps, flags, T-shirts, and commemorative items of no commemorative value. They were sold as heirlooms at an heirloom price, and now they’re being sold as clearance.
Across America, thousands of garages have at least one box of them wedged between a broken exercise bike and last year’s Christmas decorations, waiting for the next garage sale to explain what happened to them.
The show itself is built like a conductor backed by a full orchestra. The opening strains are almost gentle. Then, thirty minutes in, the volume rises, the tempo quickens, and every instrument in the pit is played a little harder: spiced with a healthy dose of grievance and resentment, a dash of hate.
By the end of the first hour, the faithful were on their feet, chanting “USA, USA” or “lock her up”, with the glazed devotion of people who have forgotten what the words were for or even about.
The diatribe ebbed and flowed, and the lies grew ever larger until fact-checking a rally was like fact-checking a fireworks display.
This is the part I can never look away from, and it’s what I blame dictators for. His audience were not monsters. They were dentists, plumbers and grandmothers, in other words, perfectly ordinary, law-abiding people who walk in as neighbours and, within an hour, become a mob. Think of a single concrete image you saw on television. That selfsame plumber, lawyer or grandmother, a face in the crowd, whose face is now distorted into a mask of hate, screaming at invisible demons. It becomes a moment you remember.
And here’s what has always confused me. Trump doesn’t speak well. There’s no argument being built, no conviction, just disjointed syllables fired off like bullets, each one designed to charge the room. He can’t gear down for the “simple” people he claims to speak for. He needs them furious. When a protester is attacked and bodily hauled out, he watches, amused, and encourages it.
Self-centred, arrogant, and so sure of himself that it’s unhealthy: that’s a dictator’s temperament, whatever title is on the door.
But here is the good news, and it’s very dry good news. The show needs an audience, and he has lost the one thing that kept the tour running: another election to win. He’s a lame duck now. The rallies have no purpose beyond the sound of their own applause, and the merchandise isn’t selling, never mind appreciating.
You no longer have to watch the clips on YouTube and share them with “can you BELIEVE this?” and a skull emoji. Never forget, every outraged viewer is a ticket sold. He will never run out of things to say, but he is on the fast track to running out of listeners.
Change the channel. Let him play to an empty house, and leave the caps in the garage, preferably at the bottom of the box.
